Rechercher dans ce blog

Thursday, February 2, 2023

Regulating artificial intelligence: Things are about to get a lot more interesting - CBC.ca

This column is an opinion by Jonah Prousky, a management consultant based in Toronto, focusing on data, analytics and artificial intelligence. For more information about CBC's Opinion section, please see the FAQ.

On May 12, 1997, the front page of the New York Times read, "Swift and Slashing, Computer Topples Kasparov."

The article, for those who may not remember, broke the news about one of the most infamous chess matches of all time, in which an IBM supercomputer, Deep Blue, defeated reigning world chess champion Garry Kasparov in six games. 

For many, this was far more than a chess match between man and machine. It was a sign that the gap was closing between artificial intelligence (AI) and human intelligence. And in a big way. 

OpenAI's release of ChatGPT will go down as another extraordinary encounter between man and machine. Only this time, it isn't a game. Language and its infinite applications are at stake. 

Not coincidentally, Garry Kasparov's words when reflecting on his loss to Deep Blue 10 years later in an interview with the CBC seem most appropriate for this moment. "I always say, machines won't make us obsolete," he said. "Our complacency might."

And while it doesn't look like ChatGPT will in fact make us obsolete, it has provided us with a sobering reminder of AI's potential to disrupt many aspects of the human experience: education, medicine, law, commerce, and everything in between. 

In response, we need to be mindful of Kasparov's words and fight our tendency toward complacency. We, most notably our politicians, need to manage the future of AI, not vice versa. 

A regulatory conundrum

Members of the House of Commons are currently mulling over Bill C-27, the Digital Charter Implementation Act, which includes what could become Canada's first piece of AI legislation, the Artificial Intelligence and Data Act (AIDA).

If passed, the AIDA would place several guardrails on the uses of AI and enforce penalties for noncompliance up to $25 million. 

This is certainly a step in the right direction, though it's easy to foresee several challenges the AIDA or any policy like it will face when enacted.

Firstly, technology develops exponentially, but the legislative process is linear, where bills plod through the House and Senate before being passed into law. It might be many months or years before AI legislation is passed, yet it's difficult to predict what AI will be capable of at that point. 

Managing risks that grow exponentially has been acutely challenging in the past. Consider how badly COVID-19, which came in exponential spikes, stressed hospital capacity and other essential services. 

I think that's the speed at which AI will spread as the technology improves. It took less than one week for ChatGPT to amass over one million users. What's more, the next, more powerful iteration of the software has already been announced by OpenAI. 

Secondly, AIDA is chiefly concerned with uses of AI that are deliberately harmful, such as data privacy breaches or financial crime. But it's the grey zones that are more concerning. In education, for example, some have posited that this new step forward in AI will make homework a thing of the past. But will that make the next generation of students more or less intelligent? 

Zoom out, and many of the applications of AI — in social media, or national defence, perhaps — start to look the same way. That is, they may not be deliberately harmful but their net effect on society is largely unknown. 

Thirdly, corporations will ultimately own this technology and that has the potential to be both a blessing and a curse. 

Microsoft is poised to invest an additional $10 billion in OpenAI and, like any corporation, will have a fiduciary responsibility to maximize profits for its shareholders. This isn't necessarily a bad thing. Consider how quickly corporations developed and distributed vaccines for COVID-19. The incentive to use AI to turn a profit may lead to the next breakthrough in science or medicine.

However, when corporate and social interests are at odds, corporations have a funny way of getting what they want — usually through effective government lobbying. If there are profitable applications of AI that are detrimental to society, AI legislation alone might not be enough to stop them. 

The path forward

Canada's proposed AI legislation is lenient enough to allow for a future where many aspects of human life are augmented by AI. The technology is arguably in its infancy, yet already capable of carrying out highly nuanced tasks such as weeding through job applications, predicting verdicts in legal trials or diagnosing sick patients. 

It will be fascinating to watch regulators ponder the ethical boundaries of life with AI, and nobody knows exactly how this will play out. 

In the years that followed Kasparov's defeat, Deep Blue's successors, such as Google's AlphaGo, got a lot more powerful. But what people tend to forget is that the technology made human chess players better as well. 

AI didn't make chess obsolete. In fact, it made the game more interesting.

ChatGPT has many flaws. It struggles a bit with ambiguity, and it has a so-far-amusing tendency to present false information as fact. In that sense, ChatGPT looks more like the Deep Blue from Kasparov's first bout with it in 1996, where Kasparov came out ahead four games to two. 

If history repeats itself, ChatGPT and its successors will continue to improve and encroach on many aspects of human intelligence. Along the way, things will get a lot more interesting. 

Our job, as Garry Kasparov reminded us, will be to guard against complacency.


Do you have a strong opinion that could add insight, illuminate an issue in the news, or change how people think about an issue? We want to hear from you. Here's how to pitch to us.

Adblock test (Why?)


Regulating artificial intelligence: Things are about to get a lot more interesting - CBC.ca
Read More

Wednesday, February 1, 2023

After more than 3 decades, West Edmonton Mall's Mindbender roller-coaster closes for good - CBC.ca

The Mindbender roller-coaster, a fixture for decades at Galaxyland in West Edmonton Mall, has come to the end of its triple-looped track.

In a news release this week, the mall confirmed the closure of the "iconic" roller-coaster that had thrilled riders since it opened in 1985.

"While the Mindbender will be missed, we are excited to announce that we are working on groundbreaking new plans for family thrills that will immerse our guests in an out-of-this-world experience," Lori Bethel, WEM's vice-president of parks and attractions, said in the release.

Redevelopment of the area has begun and the roller-coaster will be decommissioned and removed, the mall said.

The Mindbender, dubbed the world's largest indoor triple-loop roller-coaster, had been closed to the public since 2020.

The ride gave adrenalin rushes to untold thousands of thrill-seekers over the years, but its reputation was tarnished by a 1986 accident that killed three people and critically injured another.

People riding a rollercoaster indoors.
The Mindbender roller-coaster in action at Galaxyland in West Edmonton Mall. The mall announced the permanent closure of the ride on Monday. (BestEdmontonMall.com)

Matthew Dutczak, a self-proclaimed WEM historian and creator of the Best Edmonton Mall YouTube channel, said he was shocked to learn the ride was permanently closing. 

"I heard the rumours like everyone did over the last few years, and I was the biggest, most vocal opponent of it at the thought of it closing," he told CBC.

"I never in a million years thought they would close it."

Dutczak recalls being too scared to ride the Mindbender when he was young. But after he picked up the courage to ride it as a teenager, he was hooked. 

"And now I'll never get to ride it again, which is very sad," he said.

From a tourism perspective, the roller-coaster made for one of the mall's most iconic images, right after the pirate ship and indoor waterpark, Dutczak said. It was featured in the majority of tourism photos he has seen of the mall, he said. 

The ride was a favourite of roller-coaster enthusiasts like Andrew Cunningham from San Francisco, who has been on 717 roller-coasters around the world.

Radio Active6:07The Mindbender is no more

We talk to a roller coaster enthusiast from San Francisco about Edmonton's legendary indoor attraction.

Cunningham told CBC's Radio Active on Monday the Mindbender was popular with enthusiasts because of its intensity.

"It has a very long ride time and it's a very aggressive ride," he said.

"It goes upside down three times — extremely powerful loops; they're not just like little floaty things. You get really pushed down into your feet throughout the entire ride."

The roller coaster ranked No. 4 for highest G-force — short for gravitational force — on Coasterpedia, an online resource about roller-coasters and other amusement rides.

Cunningham said that in his experience, most roller-coasters transition out of the high G-force to give riders a chance to breathe and recover. 

"But the thing about Mindbender is it was just relentless [in] how long it held those G-forces for, and it really just pins you to the seat throughout the entire ride," he said.

1986 fatal crash

On June 14, 1986, the ride's last car derailed at about 100 kilometres per hour, hitting a concrete pillar and hurling four passengers to the concrete floor below.

Three of the ejected riders died and the fourth was critically injured. Nineteen other riders were treated for minor injuries.

The ride shut down for more than a year and underwent safety modifications. ​​​​​

A provincial inquiry blamed the crash on a defunct West German company for design and manufacturing flaws. The inquiry found that four bolts had worked loose, allowing a wheel assembly to fall off the roller-coaster car.

Edmontonian Brian McMorran was on the ride with his friends a day before the crash. 

"It really rattled me," he told CBC on Monday. 

McMorran never rode the roller-coaster again. 

"It could have just as easily been me and my friends," he said. 

Dean De Benedetto, who was 15 when he worked at the amusement park in 1987, remembers the Mindbender being the most fun ride in Edmonton, but also the scariest.

"I do remember thinking about it a few times," he said, referring to the crash. 

"When you're on the ride, you're just like, 'We only hope this thing holds together.'"

Many of De Benedetto's colleagues at the amusement park — then known as Fantasyland — were around his own age and ran most of the rides, he said.

But the Mindbender was supervised by adult employees.

"It was kind of the one, the one ride that you had to have a bit of a bit of technical expertise to run, from what I remember," he said.

Edmonton AM6:40Mindbender rollercoaster shutting down for good

West Edmonton Mall's Mindbender rollercoaster is being shut down for good. The ride has been out of service for months, but mall officials confirmed it's being removed and replaced. The news has some looking back at 37 years of memories. With more reaction on the closure, we're joined by Matthew Dutczak. He's the creator of Best Edmonton Mall and a mall historian.

Adblock test (Why?)


After more than 3 decades, West Edmonton Mall's Mindbender roller-coaster closes for good - CBC.ca
Read More

Enzo Fernandez transfer news: Chelsea complete British record £107m fee for Benfica midfielder - BBC

Enzo Fernandez

Chelsea have agreed a British record 121m euro (£107m) deal with Benfica for Argentina midfielder Enzo Fernandez.

The deal eclipses the £100m Manchester City paid for Jack Grealish in 2021.

Fernandez, who only joined Benfica for a reported £10m in August, was named young player of the tournament during Argentina's World Cup triumph in Qatar.

The 22-year-old's arrival takes Chelsea's January spending to £289m, according to transfer website Transfermarkt.

He has signed an eight-and-a-half year contract at Stamford Bridge.

The deal follows an outlay of £270m in the summer - a record for a British club in the summer window.

It is the joint-sixth most expensive signing of all-time, equalling the 120m euros Barcelona paid for France forward Antoine Griezmann in 2019.

Graphic showing the most expensive signings in British football

Fernandez, signed by Benfica from Argentine side River Plate, has scored four goals in 29 appearances for the Primeira Liga side.

Benfica confirmed on Tuesday night that River Plate will earn 25% of the transfer fee, around 30m euros.

He scored once during the World Cup, netting Argentina's second goal in their 2-0 group-stage win over Mexico.

Earlier in January, Benfica accused Chelsea of trying to unsettle the midfielder, with the Portuguese side's manager Roger Schmidt declaring their pursuit "closed".

Chelsea have signed Noni Madueke, Mykhailo Mudryk, David Datro Fofana, Andrey Santos, Benoit Badiashile and Malo Gusto on permanent deals in January.

They have also brought in Joao Felix on loan from Atletico Madrid.

The Blues are 10th in the Premier League, 10 points adrift of the competition's Champions League places after 20 matches.

The club was bought for £4.25bn by a consortium led by American investor Todd Boehly last May, after previous owner Roman Abramovich was sanctioned over his links to Russian president Vladimir Putin.

Adblock test (Why?)


Enzo Fernandez transfer news: Chelsea complete British record £107m fee for Benfica midfielder - BBC
Read More

Tuesday, January 31, 2023

James Webb Telescope: More stars created Southern Ring Nebula - CTV News

The central star forming the Southern Ring Nebula is dying, emitting the "messy" red dust that forms its titular rings, and researchers now understand the phenomenon visible through a high-powered telescope is caused by multiple stars, not just one.

A team of 70 researchers found there were two or more "unseen" stars that created the circular shapes around the nebula.

A nebula, as described by NASA, is a term for a cloud of dust and gas in space formed from the explosion of a dying star.

The Southern Ring Nebula is about 2,000 light-years away from Earth.

The team behind the research, led by Orsola De Marco of Macquarie University in Sydney, analyzed 10 of NASA's James Webb Telescope images and existing data from the European Space Agency’s Gaia observatory.

The discovery was published in Nature Astronomy on Dec. 8.

"With Webb, it’s like we were handed a microscope to examine the universe," De Marco said in NASA's press release."There is so much detail in its images. We approached our analysis much like forensic scientists to rebuild the scene. "

The Southern Ring Nebula is aging, which is why researchers are interested in how it was created and what is happening. The processes of the dying star created red gas forming the nebula, making for what researchers call a "messy death."

"We think all that gas and dust we see thrown all over the place must have come from that one star, but it was tossed in very specific directions by the companion stars," Joel Kastner, a team member from the Rochester Institute of Technology in New York, said in NASA's press release.

The team was able to pinpoint the mass of stars that created the nebula, which shows the central star was nearly three times bigger than the sun at the time. After it started shedding layers of gas and dust, which happens as stars age, the team was able to see how many stars created the shapes of the Southern Ring Nebula.

"Knowing the initial mass is a critical piece of evidence that helped the team reconstruct the scene and project how the shapes in this nebula may have been created," the NASA website reads.

The team believes the central star interacted with one or two small companion stars which spread out the dusty red gas seen circling around.

By understanding how the nebula got its rings, researchers can apply the evidence to other systems in deep space answering questions on how stars are created and why the dust forms circles. 

Adblock test (Why?)


James Webb Telescope: More stars created Southern Ring Nebula - CTV News
Read More

Stocks making the biggest moves midday: GM, McDonald's, UPS, Pulte, International Paper and more - CNBC

In this article

General Motors CEO Mary Barra speaks to reporters while she waits for the arrival of President Joe Biden at media day of the North American International Auto Show in Detroit, Michigan, September 14, 2022.
Rebecca Cook | Reuters

Check out the companies making headlines in midday trading Tuesday.

General Motors — The automaker's stock surged more than 7% after the company cruised past analyst estimates on the top and bottom lines for its fourth quarter. The company reported an adjusted $2.12 per share on $43.11 billion in revenue. Analysts surveyed by Refinitiv were looking for $1.69 in earnings per share on $40.65 billion in revenue. The outperformance came despite profit margins narrowing year over year. GM also said it expected earnings to fall in 2023, but that guidance was still above analyst estimates.

Caterpillar — Shares fell about 3% after Caterpillar reported a 29% earnings decline. The construction machinery and equipment maker said higher manufacturing costs and foreign currency effects weighed on its quarterly results.

Paramount — Shares of the entertainment giant shed 1% after a downgrade to underperform from neutral by Macquarie, which cited its exposure to advertising. CNBC reported Monday that the company will integrate Showtime's streaming service into its main streaming platform, Paramount+.

A.O. Smith — Shares skyrocketed 9.6% after the manufacturing company reported earnings of $0.86 per share, beating consensus estimates. The company has beat EPS estimates three times over the last four quarters.

McDonald's — Shares dipped 2.60% after McDonald's reported its latest quarterly results. Although the fast food company's earnings and revenue beat expectations, management cautioned that rising cost pressures are likely to continue in 2023.

UPS — Shares of United Parcel Service gained 4% after shipping and transportation giant posted earnings of $3.62 a share, slightly ahead of the $3.59 expected by analysts surveyed by Refinitiv. UPS also raised its dividend and sanctioned a new $5 billion stock repurchase plan.

PulteGroup — Shares of the homebuilder soared 9% in midday trading after the company reported better-than-expected fourth quarter earnings. The company reported $3.63 in adjusted earnings per share on $5.17 billion of revenue, and its homebuilding gross margin rose year over year.

International Paper — Shares of the packaging and paper products company rallied more than 8% after reporting fourth-quarter adjusted operating earnings of 87 cents per diluted share, exceeding StreetAccount's estimate of 69 cents per diluted share. International Paper also gave fiscal year 2023 guidance of $2.8 billion compared to the $2.4 billion expected.

Pentair — Shares of Pentair surged 6.7% after the water treatment company reported earnings that topped Wall Street estimates for earnings and revenue. The company also gave solid forward guidance for earnings for the full year 2023.

Lam Research — Shares were up 2.3% after Citi added a positive catalyst watch on the semiconductor company and said it expects the stock to outperform.

— CNBC's Samantha Subin, Alex Harring, Jesse Pound, Yun Li, Carmen Reinicke, Michelle Fox Theobald, and Hakyung Kim contributed reporting.

Adblock test (Why?)


Stocks making the biggest moves midday: GM, McDonald's, UPS, Pulte, International Paper and more - CNBC
Read More

Black Americans Are Much More Likely to Face Tax Audits, Study Finds - The New York Times

A new report documents systemic discrimination in how the I.R.S. selects taxpayers to be audited, with implications for a debate on the agency’s funding.

WASHINGTON — Black taxpayers are at least three times as likely to be audited by the Internal Revenue Service as other taxpayers, even after accounting for the differences in the types of returns each group is most likely to file, a team of economists has concluded in one of the most detailed studies yet on race and the nation’s tax system.

The findings do not suggest bias from individual tax enforcement agents, who do not know the race of the people they are auditing. They also do not suggest any valid reason for the I.R.S. to target Black Americans at such high rates; there is no evidence that group engages in more tax evasion than others.

Instead, the findings document discrimination in the computer algorithms the agency uses to determine who is selected for an audit, according to the study by economists from Stanford University, the University of Michigan, the University of Chicago and the Treasury Department.

Some of that discrimination appears to be rooted in decisions that I.R.S. officials made over the last decade as they sought to maintain tax enforcement in the face of budget cuts, by relying on automated systems to select returns for audit.

Those decisions have produced an approach that disproportionately flags tax returns with potential errors in the claiming of certain tax credits, like the earned-income tax credit, which supplements low-income workers’ incomes in an effort to alleviate poverty. Those tax returns are more often selected for audits, regardless of how much in owed taxes the agency might recover.

The result is audit rates of Black Americans that are between three and five times the rate of other taxpayers, even when comparing that group to other taxpayers who also claim the E.I.T.C.

The I.R.S. does not detail how it selects returns for audit. But the researchers were able to isolate several apparent explanations for why Black taxpayers are targeted so much more frequently. One is complexity: It is much harder for the agency to audit returns that include business income, because that process requires expertise from individual auditors. Such returns appear to be audited less often than returns from otherwise similar taxpayers who do not report income from a business.

Black taxpayers are far less likely than others to report business income. And Black taxpayers appear to disproportionately file returns with the sort of potential errors that are easy for I.R.S. systems to identify, like underreporting certain income or claiming tax credits that the taxpayer does not qualify for, the authors find.

In effect, the researchers suggest that the I.R.S. has focused on audits that are easier to conduct and as a result, finds itself disproportionately auditing a historically disadvantaged group rather than other taxpayers, including high net-worth individuals.

“What the I.R.S. chooses to focus on when it conducts audits can either undercut or complement our progressive tax system,” said Daniel Ho, an author of the study who is the faculty director of Stanford’s Regulation, Evaluation and Governance Lab, known as RegLab, where the study originated.

Black taxpayers are at least three times as likely to be audited by the Internal Revenue Service as other taxpayers.Hiroko Masuike/The New York Times

The I.R.S. could instead program its algorithms to target audits toward more complicated returns with higher potential dollar value to the government if an audit found errors. In that case, the discrimination in the system would vanish, the authors concluded.

“Historically, there has been this idea that if federal agencies and other policymakers don’t have access to data on race and don’t explicitly take race into account when making policy decisions and allocating resources, the resulting outcome can’t be structurally biased,” said Evelyn Smith, an author of the paper who is a University of Michigan economics graduate student and visiting fellow at Stanford’s RegLab.

One lesson from the study, she said, “is that absolutely is not true.”

On his first day in office, President Biden signed a series of executive orders seeking to advance racial equity in the federal government and the nation. One of them included a directive to the White House budget office to “study methods for assessing whether agency policies and actions create or exacerbate barriers to full and equal participation by all eligible individuals.”

That order inspired researchers at the RegLab, which uses machine learning and other advanced techniques to help governments improve policies. It eventually yielded the study, which the authors will present publicly on Tuesday. It was conducted by Stanford researchers including Ms. Smith, Mr. Ho and Hadi Elzayn, along with Thomas Hertz and Robin Fisher of the Treasury Department’s Office of Tax Analysis, Arun Ramesh of the University of Chicago and Jacob Goldin of Chicago and Treasury.

The group wanted to use machine learning to improve the federal auditing process, and they wanted to know if that process was infused with racial bias. But they couldn’t easily observe it, because the I.R.S. does not ask taxpayers to declare their race on tax forms, or otherwise track race in any way.

President Biden signed an executive order to “study methods for assessing whether agency policies and actions create or exacerbate barriers to full and equal participation by all eligible individuals.”Doug Mills/The New York Times

Instead, the researchers built a way to essentially fill in the blanks on taxpayer race, through a partnership with Treasury that gave them access to 148 million tax returns and 780,000 audits, primarily from 2014, but ranging from 2010 to 2018.

They used taxpayer names — first and last — and the census demographics of their neighborhoods to effectively guess the race of any given filer. Then they examined those results in a small sample of returns from taxpayers who had reported their race elsewhere, on state election forms, in order to be confident that their estimates were correct.

The eventual findings were stark and surprising, the authors said. They saw an immediate correlation between the racial composition of neighborhoods and the audit rates in those areas — vivid signs of significantly higher audit rates for Black taxpayers.

Black Americans are disproportionately concentrated in low-wage jobs. They are more likely than whites to claim the E.I.T.C. The authors wondered if that prevalence in claiming the credit might explain why Black taxpayers face more audits, because IRS data show the agency audits people who claim the E.I.T.C. at higher rates than other taxpayers.

But as the research progressed, the authors found the share of Black Americans claiming the E.I.T.C. only explained a small part of the audit differences. Instead, more than three-quarters of the disparity stems from how much more often Black taxpayers who claim the credit are audited, compared to E.I.T.C. claimants who are not Black.

Treasury officials are aware of the findings. The department started an advisory committee last fall to help it focus on disparities faced by Americans of color. This month, researchers from the department published an analysis of racial disparities in the tax code. It found a wide range of tax advantages that largely help higher-income Americans, like the mortgage interest deduction and preferential tax rates for investment income, disproportionately benefit white taxpayers.

Department officials are in the process of increasing tax enforcement on high earners and corporations that do not pay what they owe, using money from a sprawling climate, health and tax bill Mr. Biden signed into law last summer.

Asked about the study this week, a Treasury spokeswoman pointed to a letter that the deputy Treasury secretary, Wally Adeyemo, wrote last fall to the I.R.S. commissioner on those enforcement efforts, which in effect prioritized cracking down on groups of high-income taxpayers.

“Historic challenges and underfunding have led to audit rates for those at the top of the distribution decreasing more than the correspondence audits of those at the bottom in the last decade, which should change,” Mr. Adeyemo wrote.

Adblock test (Why?)


Black Americans Are Much More Likely to Face Tax Audits, Study Finds - The New York Times
Read More

'More people should lose their jobs': Parents call for accountability at school where teacher was a shot - CNN

'More people should lose their jobs': Parents call for accountability at school where teacher was a shot

Nearly a month after a 6-year-old allegedly shot his teacher inside a classroom, students a Richneck Elementary are returning to class and navigating new safety protocols. CNN's Brian Todd reports.

Adblock test (Why?)


'More people should lose their jobs': Parents call for accountability at school where teacher was a shot - CNN
Read More

Lupus and other autoimmune diseases strike far more women than men. Now there's a clue why - CTV News

WASHINGTON - Women are far more likely than men to get autoimmune diseases, when an out-of-whack immune system attacks their own bodies -...